History

How to do the top change

Learn the top change, the classic switch of a card in your hand for the top card of the deck, using Professor Hoffmann’s 1876 method.

By The Online Magic Store

· 4 min read

Two hands crossing over a mat, a single card in the right fingertips passing near the deck in the left, backs up
In this story 8 sections
  1. What is the top change
  2. Where does the top change come from
  3. How do you set up the top change
  4. How do you do the top change
  5. How do you hide the moment the hands meet
  6. What if it keeps going wrong
  7. What helps you take it further
  8. Frequently asked questions

The top change secretly swaps a card in your hand for the top card of the deck as your hands briefly come together. The basic method goes back about 150 years: Professor Hoffmann described it in Modern Magic in 1876. The move itself is short. The real work is the cover, a natural gesture that hides the moment the hands meet.

What is the top change?

Big Blind Media puts it simply: the term “Top Change is usually understood to mean the exchange of a card with the top card of the deck.” You show a card held in one hand while the deck is in the other, then exchange the shown card for the top card of the deck. Wikipedia lists the top change among the card switches, alongside the double lift.

Where does the top change come from?

Based on our research, the earliest mention we’ve found is Professor Hoffmann in Modern Magic, 1876. His chapter on sleight of hand with cards has a section called “To ‘change’ a card” with several methods. Conjuring Archive’s top change category, which lists 256 entries, starts with an 1876 entry titled “To ‘Change’ a Card – Third Method,” and Big Blind Media also points to Hoffmann’s 1876 book as the first English description.

It was later described by S. W. Erdnase in The Expert at the Card Table (1902), whose contents list “the top change” among his changes and transformations. Conjuring Archive and Big Blind Media also both point to a 1910 description by Johann Nepomuk Hofzinser.

How do you set up the top change?

These steps follow Hoffmann’s “First Method,” for a right-handed person.

  1. The deck. Hold the deck face down in your left hand. The card you want to end up showing is already on top.
  2. The shown card. In Hoffmann’s words, “Hold the card to be changed in the right hand, between the first and second fingers.”

How do you do the top change?

  1. Push the top card over. As the hands approach each other, Hoffmann says: “Push this card a little forward with the left thumb.” The top card now sticks out from the deck.
  2. The exchange. For a moment the hands come together. Hoffmann has you “place the card held in the right hand under the pack,” while “the thumb and first finger of the right hand must close upon the card projecting from the top of the pack.”
  3. Separate the hands. In Hoffmann’s words, “as the hands separate, carry with them that card in place of the one which the right hand originally held.”

How do you hide the moment the hands meet?

Hoffmann gives several ways to cover the move. He suggests “a half turn of the body to the left or right, a quick downward sweep of the right hand, or any other rapid gesture,” which “will assist in covering the momentary bringing together of the hands.” He adds that sometimes only the right hand should move, with the left hand still, and sometimes the hand holding the pack should make the movement.

His “Third Method” takes a different approach. You bring the hands together openly, but for a reason the audience accepts, such as appearing to replace the card in the pack. As he puts it, “The main movement (that which brings the hands together) is undisguised, but attributed to a fictitious motive.” He advises aiming for a natural action rather than a fast one.

Later writers agree. Big Blind Media quotes Jean Hugard’s advice in The Royal Road to Card Magic: “First master the switch while holding the hands relatively motionless.” It also quotes Ken Brooke on using “natural misdirection brought about by natural movement.” For more on this, read our guide to misdirection principles.

What if it keeps going wrong?

  • People see the hands meet. Our suggestion: give the gesture a reason, such as pointing at a spectator or reaching for the table, so the movement feels natural.
  • The cards talk. Our suggestion: push the top card only a little, and practise slowly until the exchange is silent.
  • You rush it. Our suggestion: follow Hugard’s advice and learn it with the hands nearly still, then add the gesture. Our guide on how to practise magic can help.

The top change pairs well with the double lift, another way to make one card look like another.

What helps you take it further?

  • Modern Magic by Professor Hoffmann (free eBook). The complete 594-page book from 1876, with a sleight of hand chapter that covers the pass, the force, false shuffles, palming and the change.
  • The Expert at the Card Table by S. W. Erdnase (free eBook). The complete 230-page book from 1902, whose contents include “the top, bottom, palm and double palm changes.”

Both download for free: check out at $0 and the file arrives by email. Browse the rest of our free ebooks, or find more card magic. Curious about Erdnase himself? Read Who was S. W. Erdnase?

Frequently asked questions

What is the top change?

A sleight that secretly exchanges a card held in one hand for the top card of the deck held in the other hand.

Where does the top change come from?

Based on our research, the earliest mention we’ve found is Professor Hoffmann in Modern Magic, 1876, where it appears under “To ‘change’ a card.”

How do you hide the top change?

Hoffmann suggests covering the moment the hands come together with a half turn of the body, a quick sweep of the hand or another natural gesture, or giving the movement a believable reason.

Which free books teach the top change?

Modern Magic by Professor Hoffmann (1876) and The Expert at the Card Table by S. W. Erdnase (1902) both include it, and both are free ebooks in our store.

Free magic books The magician’s library. Classic magic books, from Erdnase to Houdini. Public domain and free to keep. Open the library ›